Pick Six Previews
  • Home
  • Preseason All-American Team
    • Preseason All-American Team - Defense
    • Preseason All-ACC Team
    • Preseason All-Big 12 Team
    • Preseason All-Big Ten Team
  • 2024 Season Preview
  • Testimonials
  • Helmet Store
    • Team Throwback Sets
    • FBS Custom Pocket Pro Helmets
    • FCS Custom Pocket Pro Helmets
EXTRAS > Trophy Case > Trophies L-P

TROPHIES: L - P

NCAA rivalry trophies; explanation, series history and current holder.

-   CURRENT MATCHUPS: WEEK 1   -


RIVALRY TROPHIES - L through P

LAND OF LINCOLN TROPHY

Peace Pipe Land of Lincoln
Illinois vs. Northwestern

All-Time Series: Illinois 55-48-5
Last 12 Games: Northwestern 8-4
Current Holder: Illinois
2015 Matchup:  Week 13

Notes:
Teams originally played for a cigar store Indian, was stolen, then played for the Sweet Sioux Tomahawk (left).  Due to                                                                                                                                                                                     NCAA regulations, the Tomahawk was discontinued in 2008.                                                                                                                                                                                 Now play for bronze Lincoln top-hat (State Nickname)

LEGENDS TROPHY

Legends Trophy
Notre Dame vs. Stanford

All-Time Series: Notre Dame 19-9
Last 12 Games: Notre Dame 8-3
Current Holder: Notre Dame
2015 Matchup: Week 13

Notes:
Teams first met in 1925, Notre Dame's Four Horsemen earned the 27-10 and the school's first National Championship.  The schools have met annually since 1988.
The trophy consists of Irish crystal on a California Red-Wood base.

LITTLE BROWN JUG

Little Brown Jug
Michigan vs. Minnesota

All-Time Series: Michigan 69-23-3
Last 12 Games: Michigan 10-2
Current Holder: Minnesota
2015 Matchup:  Week 9

Notes:
In 1903 the teams met in an elite matchup, but Michigan Coach Fielding Yost thought MN would attempt to contaminate his water. He had an assistant purchase a 5 gallon jug. After Minnesota's late touchdown,                                                                                                                                                                 the students rushed the field, ending the game in a 6-6 tie.  In the                                                                                                                                                                         excitement, Yost lost his jug, and Minnesota took possession, claiming                                                                                                                                                                 'you'll have to win it back,' thus starting the first rivalry trophy in America.                                                                                                                                                              The jug has since been painted half Blue, half Maroon, and lists the                                                                                                                                                                     scores of every game.


MAGNOLIA BOWL TROPHY

Magnolia Bowl Trophy
LSU vs. Ole Miss

All-Time Series: LSU 59-40-4
Last 12 Games: LSU 9-3
Current Holder: LSU
2015 Matchup: Week 12

Notes:
The title of "Magnolia Bowl" and the trophy are relatively new, introduced in 2008.  But this rivalry game has been played 100 times, with its biggest matchups coming in the 1950s and 1960s when they were both perennial top 10 teams. Billy Cannon's famous punt return TD came in the Tigers 7-3 win in 1959; the                                                                                                                                                                               teams rematched in the National Title Sugar Bowl with the                                                                                                                                                                                   Rebels getting revenge in their 21-0 shutout.



MAYOR'S CUP

Mayor's Cup SMU
Southern Methodist (SMU) vs. Rice

All-Time Series: SMU 48-41-1
Last 10 Games: Rice 6-4
Current Holder: Rice
2015 Matchup: NONE

Notes:
The two schools are the premier universities of their respective Texas cities: SMU of Dallas, and Rice of Houston, explaining the rivalry's name.  They were former SouthWest Conference rivals until 1996, when both joined the WAC. Currently both members of Conference USA


MEGAPHONE TROPHY

Megaphone Trophy
Notre Dame vs. Michigan State

All-Time Series:  Notre Dame 48-28-1
Last 11 years:  6-5 Notre Dame
Current Holder: Notre Dame
2015 Matchup:  NONE
             


Notes:
Introduced in 1949.
1966 matchup is considered one of the "Games of the Century" ending in a 10-10 tie between #1 and #2
The Notre Dame side is painted blue with gold lettering, while the Spartan half is white with green lettering.


MICHIGAN MAC TROPHY

Picture
Eastern Michigan vs. Central Michigan vs. Western Michigan

Winning Years:
4 - Eastern Michigan (2007, 2008, 2011, 2012)
4 - Central Michigan (2006, 2009, 2010, 2014)
2 - Western Michigan (2005, 2014)
Notes:  The Trophy is awarded to the directional Michigan school with the best head-to-head record. In the case of a split, the trophy remains with previous holder. MAC rivals

MILK CAN

Milk Can Boise Fresno
Fresno State vs. Boise State

All-Time Series: Boise State 12-5
Last 12 Games: Boise State 10-2
Current Holder: Boise State
2015 Matchup: NONE

Notes:
The Dairy industry is huge in both states, and top companies were supporters and boosters of both programs.  Two dairymen of the separate companies developed the idea of a traveling trophy between the schools.
Former WAC rivals, now Mountain West Conference rivals



OIL CAN

Milk Can Boise Fresno
Fresno State vs. San Diego State

All-Time Series: San Diego State 27-23-4
Last 12 Games: Fresno State 7-5
Current Holder: Fresno State
2015 Matchup: Week 5

Notes:
Series started in 1923 when both schools were at the Junior College level.  Both schools have shared conference affiliation off and on since; Mountain West, WAC, Independent.
The Oil Can is from the 1930s originating in Fresno but was discovered in San Diego.  Historians say it was brought by traveling Fresno State fans, who would often pack extra water and oil for the long roadtrip.  The Trophy was installed in 2011.



OLD BRASS SPITTOON

Old Brass Spittoon
Michigan State vs. Indiana

All-Time Series: Michigan State 46-14-7
Last 12 Games: Michigan State 10-2
Current Holder: Michigan State
2015 Matchup:  Week 8

Notes:
Class President Gene McDermott found the Spittoon at an antique store, and thought it would add energy to the rivalry.  It is over 190 years old, and is representative of the fishing and hunting trade-posts of the region's past


OLD OAKEN BUCKET

Old Oaken Bucket
Purdue vs. Indiana

All-Time Series: Purdue 72-39-6
Last 12 Games: Purdue 8-4
Current Holder: Indiana
2015 Matchup:  Week 13

Notes:
In 1925, Purdue and Indiana (the biggest public schools in the Hoosier State) decided to start a rivalry trophy. A 'old oaken bucket' was taken from a local farm, and the tradition began. Gold 'I's and 'P's are added after wins by the school; the IP at the top symbolizes the 0-0 tie in first trophy game 1925.


OLD WAGON WHEEL

Old Oaken Bucket
BYU vs. Utah State

All-Time Series:  BYU 46-35-3
Last 12 Games: BYU 10-2
Current Holder:  Utah State
2015 Matchup:  Week 13

Notes:
Both teams are part of the Beehive Boot three-team trophy with Utah, which is for football supremacy in the state.  On the side, these schools have played for the Old Wagon Wheel since 1948.  Despite conference realignment they will continue to play until at least 2016.


O'Rourke - McFadden Trophy

O'Rourke McFadden Trophy Clemson
Boston College vs. Clemson

All-Time Series: Clemson 13-9-2
Last 12 games: Clemson 6-5-1
Current Holder: Clemson
2015 Matchup: Week 7

Notes:
Game commemorates BC's Charlie O'Rourke and Clemson's Banks McFadden.  The two hall of famers played against each other in the 1940 Cotton Bowl.
Winning team's MVP gets to put on the leather helmet (shown in picture)


PADDLEWHEEL TROPHY

Paddlewheel Trophy
                        "River City Rivalry"
Pittsburgh vs. Cincinnati

All-Time Series: Pitt 8-4
Last 10 Games: Pitt 6-4
Current Holder: Cincinnati
2015 Matchup:  NONE

Notes:
Despite being a young rivalry, the two cities have always been sports rivals.  The PaddleWheel is symbolic of the link of the Ohio River between the cities, and how it was the means of transportation in the early 1900s.
The front lights up in the colors of the victors
Big East rivals since 2005


PANIOLO TROPHY

Paniolo Trophy Wyoming Hawaii
Hawaii vs. Wyoming

All-Time Series:   Wyoming 13-9
Last 12 Games:   Wyoming 8-4
Current Holder:    Hawaii
2015 Matchup:  NONE

Notes:
The trophy depicts a cowboy; "Paniolo" is Hawaiian for "Cowboy" which is Wyoming's mascot.  After playing annually from 1978 to 1997, the series resumed in 2013 as Hawaii joined the Mountain West. The trophy is currently lost, and there is talk of re-creating it soon (if not found).


PAUL BUNYAN's AXE  and  SLAB OF BACON

Paul Bunyan's Axe
Minnesota vs. Wisconsin

All-Time Series: Minnesota 59-57-8
Last 12 Games: Wisconsin 11-1
Current Holder: Wisconsin
2015 Matchup: Week 13

Notes:
The Slab of Bacon (pictured) was the original trophy for the rivalry, but was discontinued in 1943, as the Minnesota Head Coach felt it was wrong to accept trophies while the nation was at war.  Based on perspective and angle, the logo is wither a Wisconsin 'W'  or a Minnesota 'M'.

In 1948 Paul Bunyan's Axe became the new traveling trophy.  Each year the winning school runs over and hoists the Axe, then proceeds to pretend to 'chop' down the goalposts.

This series is the most-played rivalry in NCAA Division 1 Football.



PAUL BUNYAN TROPHY

Paul Bunyan Trophy
Michigan State vs. Michigan

All-Time Series: Michigan 68-34-5
Last 12 Games: TIE 6-6
Current Holder: Michigan State
2015 Matchup: Week 7

Notes:
First presented in 1953, Paul Bunyan is representative of the state's major lumber industry.

4 foot wooden trophy, and is mounted on a 5 foot wooden base


PLATYPUS

Platypus
                                  "Civil War"
Oregon vs. Oregon State

All-Time Series: Oregon 62-46-10
Last 12 Games: Oregon 9-3
Current Holder: Oregon
2015 Matchup: Week 13

Notes:
The "Platypus" symbolizes a combination of both school's mascots: the Duck-like Bill and the Beaver-like Tail.  Trophy was created in 1959, but was 'lost' for more than                                                                                                                                                                                        40 years, reinstated in 2006.


PURDUE CANNON

Purdue Cannon
Purdue vs. Illinois

All-Time Series: Purdue 33-28-2
Last 12 Games: Purdue 8-4
Current Holder: Purdue
2015 Matchup: Week 10

Notes:
In 1905, Purdue fans brought the cannon down to Illinois for the annual game, and planned on firing it in celebration after their expected win. Despite the win, Illini officials took the cannon.  It                                                                                                                                                                          was brought back in 1943 and introduced as a rivalry trophy.


TROPHY LINKS:  Trophy Case;   Trophies A-F;   Trophies G-K;   Trophies L-P;   Trophies R-W

 © 2022 Pick Six Previews LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Privacy Policy

  • Home
  • Preseason All-American Team
    • Preseason All-American Team - Defense
    • Preseason All-ACC Team
    • Preseason All-Big 12 Team
    • Preseason All-Big Ten Team
  • 2024 Season Preview
  • Testimonials
  • Helmet Store
    • Team Throwback Sets
    • FBS Custom Pocket Pro Helmets
    • FCS Custom Pocket Pro Helmets